Peter Grimes, Monte
Carlo, February 2018: Co-produced
with Bonn Opera, where it was presented
in the spring of 2017 before moving to the
Salle Garnier in Monte Carlo, José Cura’s
reading of Britten’s Peter Grimes (Cura
also sings the title role) is not limited
to the salt spray and accursed solitude
of the sailor. The setting he designed
does not deny the certain realistic pragmatism,
enhanced by the dim lighting, [but doesn’t
allow] this illustration to become overwhelming.
The rotation of the stage reveals different
facets of the unique setting where the promontory
of the lighthouse and the hut of the fisherman
abut a low structure, serving in turn as
a tavern or church, according to the scene,
the sanctuaries for the borough, irritants
for the harshness of Peter Grimes.
But the effectiveness of the staging serves
as social illumination more so than the
poetic abstraction to which some would be
tempted to reduce the Britten work because
of the evocation of the mystery of the seas.
Even the restraint
of the Prologue, during which Grimes appears
alone in front of a blue-gray canvas like
the sea under the moon and on which the
shadows of the court are projected, the
magistrates and townsfolk reduced to voices
as in mental ruminations, shapes the premises
of an interpretation; [the direction] is
sensitive to the psychological complexity
of the character and the situations that
restores the dialectic between nature and
society, at evidenced in both the score
and the libretto. It is not necessary
to dispense with the letter to allow the
spirit live. No transposition, no
alibi of modernity: Cura’s work focuses
first on highlighting the incarnations.
In the title
role, [Cura] defies any putative stylistic
archetype, perhaps because of the non-concealable
Latin characteristics of his vocality in
which an emotionally physical engagement
emerges. His sincerity in the role
exposes the ambivalence of this marginal
man, brutal and skin-deep, rejected by the
community, without yielding to some simplistic
aggressive male pride. José Cura undoubtedly
constitutes the pivot around which the drama
is articulated... Anaclase, 28
February 2018, GC
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/d9127/d91274087e1123d2130a0d67884b3003897247d0" alt=""
Peter Grimes, Monte Carlo, February 2018:
After
a series of sold-out performances at the
Bonn opera (co-production), Peter
Grimes premiered at the Salle Garnier
on Friday, 23 February. A “fascinating
human adventure,” a director of the Monte
Carlo Opera told us, as tenor José Cura,
adored by the Monegasque opera scene, interpreted
the title role while taking care of the
staging, the sets, and the costumes:
the result was a pessimistic vision of a
fishing village on the east coast of England
that Dickens would not have rejected.
Within the prologue,
the three acts and five luxurious musical
interludes, it is necessary to retain an
image of a triptych for this dark history:
in the first part, the dull omnipresence
of the sea is always threating, literally
a tempestuous, uninterrupted flow of notes—the
winds and bass instruments placed to the
right of the maestro—and superbly personified
by the Monte Carlo Philharmonic Orchestra.
Then, the pre-eminence in the score, the
polyphonies representing the devastating
disaster of public opinion with striking
interventions of the chorus of the Monte
Carlo opera: "Merciless tide, spare
our shores," "The old Joe left with young
Joe" or still more "Arrogant and proud,
we will destroy" in Act III. And finally,
the subtle feminine character of Ellen Orford,
a mixture of determination and empathy.
In the middle of this triangle: a
dark, irrepressibly reactive Peter Grimes.
[…]
What to say about José
Cura? Audience members commented that they
were incredibly amazed by the new performance
of the Argentinian already basking in the
glow of his previous appearances on the
Monegasque stage: the now legendary
Stiffelio in April 2013 and
more recently but equally astonishing
Tannhäuser. When the talent
of an operatic artist is able to arouse
genuine emotion, his repertoire can leave
Giuseppe Verdi and elegantly rub shoulders
with Richard Wagner and then venture with
unparalleled charm into contemporary theater.
From his impressive "Alone, Alone, Alone
with the Dead Child" signifying his initial
despair to his final "Here you are, nearly
home" through his daydreaming "In dreams,
I built myself some kindlier home" in the
presence of his apprentice, José Cura impresses
us by the irreproachable accuracy of his
tone and forces admiration by the successful
vocal and dramatic expression of this inner
chaos, of this incapacitating psychological
surge that finds its anchor only in death.
Musicologie, 24 February
2018
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/c7b24/c7b2472b6e164f368f2f741fd8c823c6bc1fe968" alt=""
Peter Grimes, Monte Carlo, February 2018:
The Monte Carlo Opera
presented the Britten's opera Peter Grimes
whose insistent and oppressive intensity
is perfectly rendered.
Peter Grimes, an opera
created by Benjamin Britten in 1945, is
one of the composer’s most powerful.
Dramatically, the tension never fades in
the adventures of this cursed fisherman
who sees two of his apprentices die in accidents:
the more this anti-hero seeks to silence
the gossip about him, the more he gives
them credence. Musically, the score
remains hectic during two hour twenty minutes
of music and offers absolutely dazzling
ensembles and catchy soloists.
José Cura, both directing
(in charge of sets and costumes with Silvia
Collazuol , and lights with Benoît Vigan)
and starring in the title role in this production,
offered a classic and literal point of view
on the work, whose purpose, still very modern,
does not need updating to find echo today.
The Prologue puts Grimes on the stage in
front of a white curtain on which are projected
the other characters in shadows. The
rest [of the action] takes place in a building
doubling as the tavern and the church, above
which looms a kind of lighthouse that serves
as Grimes’ home. Installed on a turntable
to quickly vary its aspects, the concept
worked perfectly.
The work
offers a gallery of 12 solo characters,
all with vocally complex parts, musically
interesting and dramatically important.
At their head, José Cura offers an interpretation
that embodied Peter Grimes. His imposing
and fluid voice is torn in the high-pitched
notes when he approaches them from his chest
voice, which reinforces the theatrical characterization
of the character’s pain. Conversely,
high notes emitted in mixed voice are strong
even though they may be more fragile, especially
in the "Now the Great Bear and Pleiades"
where the delicate beauty of the vocal line
is paramount. On the other hand, his
voice gushes in the air during the drinking
scene that follows, like a flash of lightning.
Ôlyrix, 21 February 2018
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/3b34e/3b34e9e99806839fa9e33b8834dfafb545b4d8ef" alt=""
Peter Grimes, Monte Carlo, February 2018:
To mount
Peter Grimes is to question the inner drama:
is he a victim, an executioner, or both
at the same time? In this new production
at the Opéra de Monte Carlo, directed by
star tenor José Cura, the first option prevails,
with a choice of a powerful confrontation
between the fisherman and the crowd, clusters
of humans moving in beautifully orchestrated
choreography. Cura offers a traditional
and realistic vision of the village (with
the inn and church mentioned in the libretto)
in the seaside town in Suffolk. Although
very present in the music, the sea is less
so in the staging, although there is a boat
and the many fishing nets that litter the
ground at the opening of the curtain are
then raised to be suspended in the flies.
Here they will stay for the duration of
the show, before being reused for the last
scene, when the nets come down little by
little during the last chords, trapping
all the inhabitants within the village.
Previously appearing
last seasons in the opera house last year
in Tannhäuser, the Argentine tenor embodies
a Peter Grimes trapped in his internal prison.
With his massive body folded in on itself,
his clumsy and brutal gestures, Cura’s Grimes
in a ball of nerves ready to explode at
any moment, evincing a physical impossibility
to exist, to live. He must be heard
singing a capella, his eyes fixed and misted,
suddenly fragile and ready to die.
What’s more, Cura displayed dazzling vocal
health, be in in the middle or high register,
modulating his instrument with ease, alternating
sumptuous piannissimi with heroic
power with a naturalness that commands
admiration. This new role is a
good one to add to Cura’s incredible list
of achievements…. Opera
Online, 28 February 2018
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/74dfd/74dfd752b76ae8ed51a1f74909aa601189e36ff7" alt=""
Peter Grimes, Monte Carlo, February 2018:
Peter Grimes culminates
in the creation of the last opera character,
after Wozzeck or Lulu, to touch our sensibilities,
to become a myth. Grimes is indeed
a man alone; arrayed before him are not
just one or two or three characters but
an entire village, the “borough” from the
title of George Crabbe’s poem.
Peter Grimes
is the story of this great tête-à-tête between
a man and everyone else, with the sea invading
everything, both the stage and the music.
Sailors' songs and raging seas, storms,
the cries of nature and elements, the call
of the marginal man whom a woman will betray,
the woman who is the only one who had helped
him and who, with her confession “O! Peter!
We have failed,“ both abandons and murders
him.
A regular on the Monegasque
scene and last year’s formidable Tannhäuser,
José Cura designed, in co-production with
the Opera of Bonn, this Peter Grimes.
The artist assumed a protean role, singing
the title role, directing, setting the staging
and designing the costumes. He created
a satisfying production because he understood
the scope of the complex psychology inherent
the role. The ensemble is encased in good-taste
classicism, the movement of the crowd is
natural without awkward poses, and the star
tenor approaches the hero by giving him
the nuances of a Lord Byron, a sort of an
uncultivated intellectual who seems animated
by a poetic gift.
Of an unusual physical
strength, with a voice almost too beautiful
for the role, between vulnerability and
contradictions, we could imagine this Grimes
wreaking havoc in
an English port bar…an image rejected by
the Argentine to remove ambiguity [and present]
a man who had suffered. With an imagination
rich enough to inspire him with the desire
to live in better conditions yet constantly
facing frustrations, José Cura’s Grimes
marvelously expresses the torments that
tear at this solitary fisherman, favoring
the figure of the hopeless, the enlightened
poet (it is necessary to hear his hallucination
in the song in the tavern) and a surly but
touched lover. Neither hero nor villain
but doubtless subtlety
disruptive…..
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/4bb79/4bb79c983f477a3125a138449b0fd58db3450fa5" alt=""
|